Rose Inn Reviews Summary

Category: Pub Atherstone

Address: Main Rd, Baxterley, Atherstone CV9 2LE, United Kingdom

Phone: +441827713939

Rating: 4.4
based on 135 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Food was delicious, with really generous portions!"
  • "The food is absolutely amazing, I had the king prawn starter, pan fried salmon and the peanut butter brownie for desert."
  • "The food here is superb this is the 3rd time we have had something to eat, the Sunday roast was great and the other meals were just as good."
  • "The roast beef is perfect, slightly pink and really tender."
  • "Had a delicious Sunday dinner of Beef, roasted potatoes & parsnips served with selection of vegetables and pan gravy."
  • "FOOD IS ABSOLUTELY LOVELY would be hard to beat within a fairly wide area."
  • "The food is just amazing."

Cons:

  • "Hunters Chicken was awful. Very tough Chicken and sent back but still charged on the bill."
  • "I had the steak and ale pie which lacked taste for me."
  • "Too much rice and very little sauce though."
  • "Food seems to have gone down in quality and presentation, still priced at a premium."
  • "Some were cooked perfectly and some were burnt. Why would you serve burnt chips?"
  • "The Yorkshire pudding was overdone and the sticky toffee pudding, I had for dessert had too much toffee sauce and only the smallest amount of custard."
  • "Whilst the portion sizes where generous, the chips left a lot to be desired, some were cooked perfectly and some were burnt."

Staff and Service

Pros:

  • "Staff really nice."
  • "Staff very friendly and attentive will definitely be returning."
  • "All the staff are lovely and friendly and excellent service."
  • "Customer service is also excellent."
  • "Amazing staff,that are so helpful."
  • "Good value and very friendly staff."
  • "Staff really friendly and efficient."

Cons:

  • "Waitress hasn’t got a clue."
  • "Service slow and staff need to switch on walking away mid order when we hadn’t finished."
  • "Food was good, however a staff member (mature women) came across rude and abruptly telling a customer she didn't do table service."
  • "Some staff in bar area very rushed and one in particular quite rude in the manner she spoke to people."
  • "Now however the staff are abrupt, everything is clearly a problem."
  • "Sadly the older gent (possibly a manager) that served us came across as grumpy and almost annoyed with us."
  • "The experience was ruined by having to ask a member of staff if they could clear our plates & 3 rounds of glasses away after we had sat with them in front of us for over an hour."

Ambiance and Decor

Pros:

  • "Lovely idyllic pub with duck pond in front and good sized carpark."
  • "The decor has changed since last visit and the makeover they've given the place is clean and fresh without too much fuss."
  • "This is a lovely country pub."
  • "Gorgeous cosy country pub with great natural surroundings."
  • "Lovely traditional pub and gardens with that nice pond."
  • "Beautiful old pub great food and ales.. also a lovely large pond to sit around on a lovely summers day."
  • "Nice decor pub and lovely setting in the village."

Cons:

  • "Bar shabby, uncomfortable and full of kids, with a choice of stools or benches to sit on."
  • "Decor particularly pictures dated and pointless in some case's."
  • "Wooden seating and picnic benches require some attention."
  • "Badly needs an update and menu rethink."
  • "Only let down is that it's all a bit dated and scruffy but when you rock up covered in hay and mud it's probably for the best!"
  • "Outside tables & benches seen better days."
  • "Dining room a bit too small tables too close to each other."

Accessibility and Accommodation

Pros:

  • "Dog friendly with beer garden with pond and ducks."
  • "Dog friendly in the bar area so we can take our labrador Daisy who gets doggie treats from staff."
  • "A perfect setting where you can look across green fields with horses and a pond complete with ducks to amuse the kids."
  • "Lovely views around outside with seating area around a nice pond."
  • "Lovely outside area to sit by the large pond."
  • "Pond next to public house is a beautiful setting for summer outside to eat or drink."
  • "Beautiful place to have a drink or a meal out."

Cons:

  • "I was tempted to deduct 1 star because I am disabled and have great difficulty queuing for the carvery also it's not wheelchair friendly so I am forced to walk with sticks which is very painful for me."
  • "The pub is on many different levels which will hard for some people."
  • "Went for Sunday lunch and spent most of the time swatting blue bottles away from the food."
  • "The pub and grounds are lovely would recommend to anyone."
  • "The vege and pork roast doesn’t come with a yorkie pud and you have to pay extra for it."
  • "Is a bit of a shame you have to pay extra for it."
  • "There was burnt mud in my baked potato which wasn't very appetising."

Value for Money

Pros:

  • "Visited this lovely place today for lunch with my Wife and family as it was her Birthday. Fantastic food, service and smiling staff."
  • "Update would now give 5β˜† under new management, pub has been refurbished, staff very polite & friendly, food excellent πŸ‘πŸ»."
  • "Really well priced."
  • "Prices are good for the quality of food."
  • "Pricing is very good too."
  • "Lovely scampi and chips with side salad tonight for just over Β£8. Generous portions."
  • "Food was really good and decent sizes."

Cons:

  • "But today they forgot my food on the order."
  • "Food is good but not plentiful."
  • "Food was good, however a staff member (mature women) came across rude and abruptly telling a customer she didn't do table service."
  • "After re opening and a change of management there has been a considerable price uplift on the Sunday Lunches and some things that were included previously have now become a slightly overpriced side order."
  • "Very disappointed used to go there when it was a carvery it was excellent whent lfor Sunday lunch very little food on plate and expensive."
  • "Sorry, but times are getting tougher and the prices are a bit too much for normal working families like ours."
  • "Thought it was a bit expensive for what it was."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.