Address: 57 Benty Ln, Sheffield, S10 5NF, United Kingdom
Phone: +441142688011
Rating: 4.1
based on 137 reviews.
Food Quality
Pros:
"Food was amazing, steaks cooked just as we like."
"Lovely food, great atmosphere, nice, friendly staff."
"Food always nice."
"the food is lovely."
"good choice of food and very tasty too!"
"Food was beautiful."
"The food was good and tasty - average size portions, which don't leave you too stuffed to move."
Cons:
"The food was horrible."
"the food was inedible over cooked dry burnt vegetables totally disgusting."
"The food was terrible i got burnt calamari starter,lasagne that was mince mush in a cheap cheese sauce don't know what happened to the pasta."
"found chicken was dry and chips all I can say is they owe me a portion."
"Steak was tough as old boots."
"Pork dry, stuffing flat, veg bland, roast potatoes as hard as rubber."
"The food was truly awful, the Sunday Roast pretty much inedible."
Staff and Service
Pros:
"Great surroundings, friendly staff, comfortable seating and nice furniture."
"Staff are very friendly and responsive. Never had any issues."
"The staff were amazing. Couldn't have asked for better."
"Friendly staff! Delicious food on a great and various menu!"
"The bar staff are lovely to top it off."
"The staff were really friendly and couldn’t have been more helpful."
"Staff are fantastic and accommodating to dogs."
Cons:
"Very slow service. Got a couple of our orders wrong."
"Was extremely upset that we waited over 45 minutes for our meals (3 Sunday carveries), only for it to be cold."
"The manager was ridiculously rude and looked like he was shaking in anger."
"Service was very slow."
"the staff was not even friendly."
"We had to wait for a long time (they were short staffed in the kitchen)."
"Had over an hour wait."
Atmosphere and Environment
Pros:
"It is a friendly cosy place."
"Really cosy at this time of year with the fire glowing and Christmas decorations."
"Nice pub with lovely welcoming atmosphere."
"Its warm, welcoming atmosphere."
"Always a great atmosphere in the Sportsman. Great for families...children always welcome. Friendly staff."
"Environment is good. Atmospheric and warm with an open fire."
"Interior design is classy and stylish and the pub has a welcoming feel."
Cons:
"Unfortunately, the new management and staff has let it down."
"The pub was cold, the radiators were cold 🥶."
"No apology, and no atmosphere."
"Not family friendly at all!!"
"I wanted to go to the toilet but I got kicked out."
"Waited nearly an hour for food even though the pub was empty on a Saturday lunchtime."
"Shame i can't leave zero stars! Can honestly say the place has gone downhill massively."
Value and Pricing
Pros:
"Booked a meal here for 20 people at short notice and got the nicest meals and service from a great team and all for a very good price."
"Food was OK and pretty good value."
"Great food and the lunchtime deal of 2 courses for £8.79 was an absolute steal."
"Pub meals of the highest level, efficiently served by pleasant, smiling staff and all at a very reasonable price."
"Fabulous meal. I had the gluten free rack of ribs. Delicious 😋 and you certainly get your money worth."
Cons:
"Standard microwaved chain pub food, over priced for the quality."
"Very expensive for run of the mill pub food."
"The drinks are so overpriced."
"Overpriced flat drinks £2.25 for a small lemonade / coke."
"Sunday lunch was priced at £11.79 for a mixed meat selection. Again poor meat portions, dry veg and bisto gravy (very little flavour) At best i would have paid £5.00 if I was asked to leave money."
Drink Selection
Pros:
"Good range of lagers and ales."
"The selection of beers was very good."
"Great surroundings, friendly staff, comfortable seating and nice furniture. A large bar with plenty of choice, serving bar food."
"Good selection of beers."
Cons:
"Had 4 different ales - Moonshine, landlord, Doom Bar and an Ember ale - every one of them was flat and tasted like acid."
"Fizzy drinks were also flat, somehow."
"When you pay over £4 a pint (a ridiculous £4.45 for one of them) you would expect the beer to be looked after properly and get a good quality drink."
"Lager - lines not cleaned correctly leaving large 'floaters' in the glass."
"Overpriced flat drinks £2.25 for a small lemonade / coke."
Special Dietary Options
Pros:
"Also the great thing about this place is, they also cater for vegans and vegetarians."
"Separate vegan menu if required."
"Super professional staff attending to my gluten free needs and quickly alerting me about the issues with genuine concern."
Cons:
"I'm gluten free not my choice but medically. Went for lunch today nothing for GF."
"Ordered a vegan pie ... It wasn't really a 'pie' as such and came with a Yorkshire pudding that wasn't vegan."
"With an allergy we were made to sign a disclaimer for my nut and peanut allergy or they would not put the order through the till!"