Address: 14 George St, Edinburgh, EH2 2PF, United Kingdom
Phone: +441316248624
Rating: 4.6
based on 610 reviews.
Food Quality
Pros:
"Delicious food, lovely wine."
"The food at the grill room is fabulous! Delicious plates, nice cocktails and incredible service."
"The vegan sausage roll and the sandwiches were delicious; the scones were amazing and so were the small desserts we had."
"Haggis appetizer outstanding, ribeye steak and lamb main course excellent."
"Both dishes I had were beautifully presented and tasted amazing."
"The food selection was lovely, especially the sandwiches."
"The food was delicious and presented beautifully."
Cons:
"Food unfortunately was mediocre/decent."
"Food was poor - turkey was dry and tasteless and fillet steak was poor quality (and v expensive)."
"The food was bland, the meat overcooked like leather."
"Collectively, these culinary missteps made for an unsatisfactory worse than mediocre overpriced letdown of a dining experience."
"It was cold though, my friend had to wrap her scarf around her legs."
"The steak pie was really tough and hard. I sent the sticky toffee pudding back."
"The food however is a let-down. I ordered the pork chop medium, and it came out well done and it was TINY."
Service
Pros:
"Lots of staff who were all very friendly and attentive."
"The service was absolutely fantastic, our waitress catered to our every needs, also having a good chat."
"The service from the staff was perfect."
"Top marks to the service team, you made us feel very special."
"Staff were friendly and attentive."
"Service was outstanding with servers politely offering to help and completing requests quickly with a smile."
"The staff were very polite, attentive and made our night more enjoyable."
Cons:
"highly disappointing the way the bar is run - you wait ages to get inside expecting to be sat at a table."
"Waited ages to pay the bill because staff had disappeared, still leaving the tables full of used plates."
"This lack of customer service left a lasting negative impression on what was already an unsatisfactory experience."
"Trying to get a second drink would have been easier to go to the bar rather than wait for the waiter to come to the table."
"The service was sloppy, the drinks came way after the starters."
"The service was a bit slow and the staff were pleasant, but there was just something missing."
"Got ignored for 20 minutes waiting at the bar."
Atmosphere & Decor
Pros:
"The Christmas decorations and trees are out of this world."
"Marvellous decor and environment a place we would come back to."
"From the moment you arrive, you are blown away by its absolutely beautiful exterior that is magical with its Christmas lights and decorations."
"The restaurant looked beautiful as it was decorated for Christmas."
"What a luxurious venue for a festive meal."
"The outdoor and indoor decorations are spectacular. Lots of people were taking photos."
"The ambience & Christmas decoration is beautiful, with the giant Christmas tree in the middle."
Cons:
"When seated at your table, there were lovely views of tables full of previous diners plates and cups, that staff didn't seem in a hurry to clear. Totally ruining the ambience."
"Decorations, as usual, were stunning but atmosphere seemed a bit flat, whereas it used to be buzzing."
"Downside to being so amazing and magical was that there was an uncomfortable amount of tourists just walking about taking pictures."
"The sandwiches were very basic, I was expecting something a little bit more elegant from a place like this."
"For such a beautiful restaurant, they really should introduce a dress code."
"The pie was excessively dry, lacking the moisture and tenderness one expects."
"The whole place is exquisitely decorated with (in my opinion) the best display in town."
Value
Pros:
"Would go there everyday if I could!"
"What a place, what food and what wonderful staff….and so reasonably priced too!"
"and so reasonably priced too!"
"For a £27 afternoon tea it wasn't bad at all."
"The price was very reasonable for the whole experience."
"The price for all was very reasonable."
"Given that a burger, chips and a beer on the royal mile costs the thick end of £30 I thought afternoon tea which is surprisingly filling and a glass of what I’m told was very nice champagne for £36 was very good value."
Cons:
"This was a £25 supplement in addition to the £42 two course set menu. A bit steep."
"I think it was also a little too expensive - please note that a 10% service charge is added to the bill."
"It’s one of our favourite days in the year."
"Unbelievely expensive (and we live in London!)"
"Not worth the price. At all."
"They try to get you to pay £42 for two courses which, as you can see from the below receipt, would mean the dessert/starter costs you £13(!!!!!)."
"A £30 service charge was added to the bill, which I feel should be optional."