The Highwayman Beefeater Reviews Summary

Category: Steak house

Address: Baslow Rd, Eastmoor, Chesterfield S42 7DA, United Kingdom

Phone: +441246566330

Rating: 4.2
based on 199 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Our server Denise W (5002) deserves special mention as she was very attentive to our needs."
  • "Jayden served us and what an absolute joy she is!"
  • "Staff was great too! Highly recommended."
  • "Kim went absolutely above and beyond in helping us manage allergies."
  • "Despite having 10 of us, the service was friendly, fast and attentive."
  • "The staff are a credit to the place."
  • "The service was efficient and the venue very clean!"

Cons:

  • "The thing that let the experience done were the serving staff."
  • "The bar staff was more interested in serving beer to themselves than customers."
  • "Table of 6 was left for 45mins had to ask to take our starter and mains order wasn't too busy either so was very disappointed."
  • "We experienced a very long wait, it was very under staffed."
  • "Very poor service, taking well over an hour to get our food, and then some meals were cold."
  • "Horrible customer service. I would avoid at all cost."
  • "Some ignorant staff."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Food was of a good standard we had Sunday lunch."
  • "Starters were great and my partners main was good."
  • "Food was excellent as were the cocktails and Irish coffees made by Dave."
  • "Steak was tasty & well cooked, very small side portions e.g. chips jacket potatoes, but on the whole, it was a nice meal."
  • "The food was hot, tasty and well presented."
  • "The food was excellent too, so much so, that we went back for a second visit before leaving for home."
  • "The food was delicious from starters through to dessert."

Cons:

  • "Place smelt musty, horrible atmosphere."
  • "Chips are dry with no crisp to them and the portion size for the price is poor."
  • "Main meal another 45 mins to come out then when it did it was awful my steak and roast potatoes were cold."
  • "The food however is overpriced and mediocre."
  • "The let down was the Bland, tasteless, poorly cooked frozen food."
  • "The food was okay...unlimited chips but you only got 6 from the offset."
  • "The food was quite good but the atmosphere was horrible."

Atmosphere & Cleanliness

Pros:

  • "First visit for 20 years and pleasantly surprised...good food nice ambiance."
  • "Very clean premises with quality fittings."
  • "Plenty of room between tables."
  • "The interior is well set out with lots of space between tables."
  • "Lovely family atmosphere and the service was efficient and very friendly."
  • "Beautiful clean environment."
  • "The restaurant is modern, clean and restful atmosphere."

Cons:

  • "This has been a favourite place of mine for nearly 20 years and in one night spoilt."
  • "Look behind till and you'll see how dirty the place is. Bottles left open. Used cutlery left about."
  • "the table we were given was away from everything in a dark corner near a draughty door."
  • "Not one smiling or happy person here. Tables are dirty."
  • "The place is looking a little bit dated now, it could do with a refurb, the staff are pleasant enough when they eventually got to serve us."
  • "This pub is really out of the way."
  • "The atmosphere of the bar was not very nice."

Value

Pros:

  • "Prices a little on the higher side but certainly doesn’t change my view of this place in any way."
  • "Kids (under 16) eat free with a paying adult, so good value if you have any."
  • "If you join the club you get discounts so it seems the prices are very reasonable if you use the offers."
  • "breakfast was exceptional value for all you can eat."
  • "The price was great too especially considering the exceptional quality of all of the food."
  • "Purchased from the lunchtime menu, great value for money."
  • "Good value for money."

Cons:

  • "Food seemed expensive."
  • "Can earn loyalty points with Beefeater card. Very noisy when busy. Reduced menu and increased prices with less on individual dishes."
  • "For over £ 3 per portion we had 4 stems of broccoli and 3 prawns Although nice very expensive."
  • "It's incredibly expensive for what you get too."
  • "Very glad we hadn't paid full price - have more vouchers but won't be using them."
  • "Food wasn’t very good at all small portions and overly priced."
  • "Everything is massively overpriced."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.