The Keys Reviews Summary

Category: Restaurant Barnsley

Address: Sheffield Rd, Hoyland, Barnsley S74 0PY, United Kingdom

Phone: +441226824437

Rating: 4.2
based on 128 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food is great and great service too, highly recommend it."
  • "The Cumberland sausage and mash for my main come out hot, presented very well and so tasty."
  • "The croquettes to start which were served beautifully and delicious."
  • "All 3 meals were delicious, very good portion size in fact quite large."
  • "The starter was spot on- great tomato soup."
  • "The Steak & Guinness Pie was the best I have tasted in a very long time."
  • "Our meals were presented well, generous portions for the price."

Cons:

  • "Come for a prebooked Christmas meal paid £80 for a 5 course meal... it was not worth £80 at all."
  • "If you don't drop on a 'deal' you'll feel you've had a mediocre, overpriced meal."
  • "The pie was overdone, hard as nails crust with the driest filling."
  • "The sandwich I had was good, fries weren't fresh though, onion rings were way too greasy so we couldn't finish them and my wife's calamari was overcooked and greasy."
  • "Been twice and had s*** food twice."
  • "Dinner was ok but burnt veg and no gravy."
  • "The pork was very dry even with the gravy, chewy the yorkshire puddings were like cardboard."

Service

Pros:

  • "However the service from the staff was exceptional, very helpful, polite and courteous."
  • "The service was extremely good. Would definitely recommend the people, place and the food."
  • "The staff are very efficient, polite & professional."
  • "Staff are attentive without being in your face."
  • "Staff friendly and helpful."
  • "The staff checked how our food was and kept taking drink orders with no wait time."
  • "Service is friendly and professional and the food is outstanding value for money."

Cons:

  • "I feel whoever is managing it isn't thinking about customers which are necessary to keep the doors open so I'd think again if I was them."
  • "We felt really unwelcome and a real sense that staff just wanted us to leave."
  • "Absolutely shocking service went for a drink with my friends service at the bar was shocking."
  • "I spoke to the manager who had a right attitude from the start and was very patronising."
  • "Service poor-wrong meals given out then asked by a staff member -would we have them instead, made to feel awkward."
  • "Waitress told us, 'she was hanging from last night. so couldn't be arsed'"
  • "Unfortunately the service we received was far from good."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "A great day out at the Keys, a man sitting outside with his guitar singing."
  • "Lovely comfortable surroundings, it's good for either a meal or just a drink sitting next to the open fire."
  • "Brilliant place to be, inside or out. Well catered for especially during covid restrictions."
  • "A fantastic way to get together with friends in a lovely, welcoming environment."
  • "The decor was very modern, the pub is very clean."
  • "The staff are always really friendly and it has a lovely atmosphere."
  • "The renovations seem to make it more upmarket and added a warmer environment."

Cons:

  • "The whole atmosphere in the pub is love and miserable."
  • "Never felt so unwelcome in a pub in my life … obviously they aren’t… so I went home unable to celebrate with my family."
  • "It was quite noisy and very hot."
  • "One member of staff in particular was coming across as a bit rude!"
  • "Never had a bad meal here."
  • "Terrible food and terrible environment."
  • "The Sunday lunch was a bit poor though both in portion size and in quality."

Value for Money

Pros:

  • "Plus it was also great value."
  • "Great home cooked food at reasonable prices. The staff are really friendly and the place is clean."
  • "Highly recommend - support your local businesses this year more than ever."
  • "GREAT VALUE FOR MONEY. GORGEOUS FOOD."
  • "Received great service for a great price."
  • "The food was fabulous. !!!! Customer service was excellent and food was excellent value for money."
  • "Good portions, excellent taste - really enjoyed it."

Cons:

  • "Drinks are so expensive also i wont be returning."
  • "We had a nice Sunday lunch today however were shocked when the bill came & were charged £7.50 for a large wine each which I think is very expensive compared to elsewhere."
  • "This place charges superstar alcohol prices! Totally unnecessary and unexpected!"
  • "Food menu was okay and varied, food was okay but felt over priced for what is was."
  • "The beef could have done with cooking longer it was tough, the meat should have fallen off the bone."
  • "Gravy was like pouring water over the meal, 2 tiny florets of cauli & broccoli generous amount of carrots all I think were frozen & the meat was no way cut from a roasted joint, more like microwave beef."
  • "Food's ok for pub food... lacks a little around some of the quality of the ingredients."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.