Address: 19 W Register St, Edinburgh, EH2 2AA, United Kingdom
Phone: +441315561884
Rating: 4.4
based on 349 reviews.
Service
Pros:
"Very impressed with service and a short wait for the kitchen to bring our meals."
"The service was friendly and gave enough space between courses that we had time to digest without wondering if anyone would ever come to check on us."
"Staff were brilliant especially the manager 'Anna'."
"The staff was efficient and a pleasure."
"Friendly, quick and professional service from staff at bar."
"The wait staff were attentive and friendly, even with the restaurant being extremely busy."
"Service and staff were great, very friendly and helpful."
Cons:
"On arrival, we were seated and after 20 minutes had to wave at the waiter to make a drinks order."
"The whole experience spoilt by quite bossy manager whos attitude influence other staff members."
"Our waiter clearly had drunk a bottle of vinegar before coming to work."
"We had to wait a while to find a seat."
"The service was frankly awful with waiters/waitresses either run off their feet or badly trained and not coping."
"We experienced rude and unhelpful staff."
"Service was very slow and uninterested."
Food Quality
Pros:
"We ordered 6 oysters - Asian which was garlic, ginger and soy - OMG these were absolutely the most beautiful, freshest oysters I've tasted."
"The shellfish platter (hot) was incredible- and we are from New England US so we know seafood! The Cesar salad was as well."
"We had bar food I.e. chips and sweet potato fries, delicious! and, I went for a yummy chocolate dessert."
"Delicious food! The mussels, steak and potato leek soup are highly recommended."
"The scallops were beautifully presented and delicious. The rest of meal was equally as lovely."
"The seafood sampler was worth every penny."
"The food was great. Tried the Scotch egg for the first time and it was delicious!"
Cons:
"It was painfully average."
"The cider batter fish & chips was really poor. The rib-eye, which was ordered medium, came as very well done."
"Starters were OK, however burgers well below par."
"All food, with the exception of the muscles and oysters, frankly fell short of expectations."
"Sadly after high expectations; quite possibly one of the worst meals of my life."
"Generously put, the food was mediocre. We sent back one dish which was inedible."
"The food was terrible. It was bland, frozen, and inedible."
Ambiance and Decor
Pros:
"A great meeting place with exotic victoriana, edwardiana and decent beers."
"The art nouveau style windows and the lovely decor make it feel like a really special place."
"Great atmosphere. Beautiful ceramics on the walls depicting important historical discoveries."
"Fabulous bar, love decor and high stools next to the bar so comfortable."
"Beautiful place with an interesting history."
"The restaurant boasts a fantastic selection of oysters and seafood dishes."
"Spectacular interior within a grand building with very interesting history."
Cons:
"The place was also dirty and there’s dust everywhere."
"A little pricey and table lighting too dim."
"£100 for two people for upmarket pub is too much"
"The portions were tiny and the prices were outrageous."
"The sofas under the window were looking a bit dirty and in contrast with the beautiful design it was a bit disappointing."
"Unfortunately the music was far too loud and very intrusive."
"The space is undeniably beautiful, hence the four stars, but it just had a weird atmosphere. A little bit stuffy or uncomfortable."
Value for Money
Pros:
"10/10 and I will definitely be back"
"Highly recommend."
"The prices were very reasonable."
"19£ for six oysters is really reasonable."
"Which as an American, I found to be incredibly reasonably priced."
"Service was attentive and it was great value for money."
"Highly recommend."
Cons:
"Food is decent but slightly pricey."
"It can be a bit pricey and it's hard to get a proper seat sometimes, but it's always worth a visit."
"Ordered another white wine and were horrified when the bill arrived for £81.84. £18.40 for 2 white wine and £12 for 1 red wine plus £7.44 service charge."
"A bit on the pricey side(a shade under £20 for a glass or wine and pint of beer)."
"It’s unjustifiably expensive and quite disappointing."
"This place is seriously overrated and badly overpriced for what you get!"
"Very expensive food and didn't have the quality to back it up."