The Hill House Reviews Summary

Category: Tourist attraction

Address: Upper Colquhoun St, Helensburgh, G84 9AJ, United Kingdom

Phone: +441436673900

Rating: 4.7
based on 267 reviews.

Visitor Experience

Pros:

  • "Definitely worth a visit."
  • "Well worth the visit both to see the design and the approach to conservation of this important heritage asset."
  • "The staff were truly amazing in terms of professional knowledge, friendliness and genuine desire that we got the most out of our visit."
  • "The guided tour was really informative and helped bring the house to life."
  • "Incredible place with amazing team of staff; every single one of them went out of their way to be kind, friendly and helpful."
  • "The staff here were outstanding: immensely friendly and knowledgeable."
  • "The staff were amazing full of info on the hoose and genuinely engaged with you."

Cons:

  • "I personally wouldn't ever wanna live in an interior that was so white."
  • "I found the staff as focused on chat with each other as on visitors and we did not engage."
  • "Bitterly disappointed."
  • "I did not like the Hill House. It is very old, and frankly, past its best."
  • "Very drab forbidding looking building and it gets worse on the inside."
  • "I was informed by a rude receptionist, not at this attraction."
  • "Very gloomy. Blinds and v low light made it difficult to see everything. Not at all safe for those with mobility problems, ditto visual impairment."

Architecture & Design

Pros:

  • "The intricate wall coverings marked the interest and hobbies of the Blackie family who owned and lived in this house for many years."
  • "The house itself is absolutely amazing, from the delicate wood work to the high back chairs, from the lamp shade to the stained glass, it’s full of details and uniqueness!"
  • "The best example of Mackintosh design, both architectural and interior."
  • "A great example of Charles Rennie Mackintosh work."
  • "Very impressive architecture from Charles Rennie Mackintosh."
  • "Loved the Charles Rennie Mackintosh design including decor, furniture and light fittings."
  • "A truly wonderful example of Rennie Mackintosh."

Cons:

  • "The entire house is now covered in a huge metal and netting shroud to preserve it so it's not visible like the picture above."
  • "Disappointing when you first see the house as it is covered all round with a metal net construction."
  • "The box round the outside does hinder your views out the window looking at the coast and surrounding area."
  • "The whole building is now encased in a huge steel cage to protect it from the elements (at least for the next few years), so the exterior cannot now be seen against the beautiful skyline."
  • "Externally, the design was flawed from day one and the building couldn't withstand Scottish weather."
  • "Unfortunately it has caused some considerable damage to the place already."
  • "It needs £1.5 million to put right the bad design and materials."

Facilities & Accessibility

Pros:

  • "Good WC facilities. Reasonable choice of food from the cafe at the usual NTS prices."
  • "The cafe is great too with lovely food and friendly staff."
  • "Decent parking available."
  • "Parking was ample and free, toilet facilities great and the shop was well stocked."
  • "The cafe is excellent and is also accessible via a lift."
  • "Very accessible for wheelchair users in the ground floor of Hill House and we were provided a guide book to allow the wheelchair user to see what was upstairs."
  • "NTS have done a good job of making the place as accessible as possible, with a lift to the café and the walkway around the house."

Cons:

  • "I must admit I found the entry fee really expensive and would be prohibitive for many families."
  • "£10.95 for a ploughman's lunch, £6.50 for a sandwich and £2.95 for a scone is totally out of order."
  • "The ramp supplied to the back entrance is rather narrow for a wheelchair."
  • "The abundant deep gravel surrounding the building is very difficult for any wheelchair, power or otherwise."
  • "I have deducted one star from my review mark as disabled wheelchair access has really not been thought through."
  • "It is at the top of a long and steep hill. It is a very long way from the shops and cafes, and has no public transport near by."
  • "Parking was a problem not sure if the gate opens at certain times."

Conservation & The 'Box'

Pros:

  • "Really interesting to see the conservation work - the Box is genius and allows visitors to get a different perspective of the house."
  • "You have to see the 'box' as they call it. Put up to protect the whole house from further rain damage."
  • "The metal box currently over the house to prevent further water damage can be walked over to give unusual rooftop views."
  • "The exterior structure has walkways around and over the top of the house that enable a closer view of the architecture."
  • "The box that surrounds the house give the visite a new and unique perspective."
  • "The covering box was amazing and the walkway enabled close aerial views of the house which was such a unique experience."
  • "The new 'box' structure is a necessary compromise that protects the building yet also gives the opportunity to see it from a different perspective."

Cons:

  • "The protective metal mesh is a little intrusive to the view but it's still worth climbing for."
  • "The 'box' which surrounds the house was erected to prevent too much rainwater from reaching the building, giving the house a chance to dry out."
  • "The first phase metal cage has walkways give a unique view of the outside of Hill House - including the roof - that not even Charles Rennie Mackintosh, the architect, would have been able to enjoy!"
  • "The house is now fully enclosed in a chain mail box. It sounds odd, but it works very well."
  • "The house has just been encompassed in a massive protective mesh by the Scottish National Trust in an endeavour to preserve it."
  • "The Box in place to protect the structure is itself a modern architectural achievement and in many ways adds to the attraction."
  • "The house is now contained within the 'box' incredible piece of engineering."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.