The Gardeners Arms Reviews Summary

Category: Pub Oxford

Address: 39 Plantation Rd, Oxford, OX2 6JE, United Kingdom

Phone: +441865559814

Rating: 4.5
based on 129 reviews.

Staff and Service

Pros:

  • "The bar staff are amazing, so so kind and helpful."
  • "Wonderful service and delicious food."
  • "The staff were super friendly, great atmosphere and the food was delicious."
  • "Great service from two lovely guys."
  • "The staff are extremely friendly and they have quiz nights."
  • "Service was fantastic. Very attentive and friendly."
  • "The owners were exceptional with their service."

Cons:

  • "Awful. We were met by a charmless woman."
  • "Surly service - it was a relatively quiet afternoon when I arrived. Yet after serving the man before me, the woman behind the bar didn’t acknowledge me for two minutes."
  • "Table service only which would be ok if the table service was any good, two bar staff behind the bar totally ignoring us."
  • "The service is a bit inattentive as well as I had to go up to the bar area to get them to take an order and to pay."
  • "Some of the staff can be a little curt and unfriendly."
  • "The service was simply dreadful."
  • "The worst experience I’ve ever had at a restaurant. The waiter yelled at us as we entered the establishment."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Great atmosphere, food is modern classic."
  • "The most delicious veggie and vegan food."
  • "The 'spicy chicken' kebab bowl is filling and varied enough to satiate a hungry diner."
  • "The food is amazing and the service is really friendly and nice."
  • "The food, which is fully vegan/vegetarian was amazing. Great size portions and was so tasty."
  • "The vegetarian mushroom pie and still can't believe how tasty it was."
  • "The best (vegan) burger I’ve ever had."

Cons:

  • "However, they serve it now with chips rather than roasted new potatoes."
  • "I ordered the veggie burger and it tasted quite weird. Looked inside and there was some mold on the patty."
  • "The food (hotdogs, burgers, curry, salad, pizza) were all sub-par."
  • "The food had nothing much to recommend it, and there seemed to be mountains of chips which were mostly left."
  • "We had 3 dishes, all of which were bland and badly prepared."
  • "The calzone looked more like a peta bread than calzone."
  • "Sadly when it arrived it was a standard size and after an easy finish of the dish I was left still pretty hungry."

Ambience and Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "Very cosy, friendly and welcoming, nice music and great decoration."
  • "Great atmosphere, half-pub half-restaurant."
  • "Lovely pub with beautiful back garden and very good food."
  • "Proper beer in a relaxed and friendly atmosphere."
  • "The atmosphere is hilarious, from chanting and singing along, to wry and sardonic commentary."
  • "Welcoming atmosphere, with a great mixed crowd of interesting people and good beer."
  • "It’s an absolute haven for anyone veggie or vegan."

Cons:

  • "Uncomfortably hot in the summer because they won't open the window."
  • "Weird place, no atmosphere or music, just owners/bar staff watching TV with subtitles."
  • "The ambience is a bit off-putting with the music played, sometimes directly above your head."
  • "The atmosphere is rather dingy, one is, to put it mildly, not given a joyous welcome by the staff."
  • "Back street local, retains table service only, which detracts from the pub experience."
  • "The atmosphere is rather dingy, one is, to put it mildly, not given a joyous welcome by the staff."
  • "Toilets and backyard need definitely a revamp."

Location and Facilities

Pros:

  • "Great location with a brilliant, spacious garden."
  • "This is a gem of a place tucked away in the residential streets of Jericho."
  • "The garden is lovely in summer."
  • "A secluded local pub with great deep garden."
  • "The garden has recently been improved with nice covered areas."
  • "There is also a large backyard filled with picnic tables."
  • "A real Victorian pub, great heavy metal music, good beers and such a great find down a back road."

Cons:

  • "visited it on a night out, no real ale only craft citrus ale! small inside but garden was ok."
  • "Only issue is extremely small bathroom."
  • "No food after 20:00 on Sundays?"
  • "Note that the drinks (i.e. beer and wine) are not guaranteed to be vegetarian."
  • "some beers are cloudy and undrinkable, if you complain your told to pay up 😑"
  • "The beer isn't that great."
  • "The interior looks a bit aged with records lining the walls."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.