The Sitwell Arms Reviews Summary

Category: Pub Rotherham

Address: Pleasley Rd, Whiston, Rotherham S60 4HQ, United Kingdom

Phone: +441709377003

Rating: 4.1
based on 145 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food when it did come was very nice indeed."
  • "The food was really nice."
  • "The food was delicious. 100% will go back."
  • "The food was very good."
  • "Good absolutely delicious, the service 5 star."
  • "The food and staff were amazing and the place is so lovely to be in."
  • "The food was even better than previously. Beautifully cooked veges and meat."

Cons:

  • "All in all a waste of money and a disappointing birthday celebration."
  • "The meals that came were poor at best and management gave excuses."
  • "Ordered sea bass with veg and new potatoes for 4 people but had to send them all back as the meals were all cold."
  • "The food was poor."
  • "When the arrived the fries 🍟 were under cooked ...the stake kebab had a lot fat making not uneatable."
  • "the pie was cold obviously not been probed before coming out had to send it back to be microwaved pastry then soggie"
  • "Food was abysmal."

Service

Pros:

  • "all the staff and locals in there was really welcoming"
  • "a pleasant young waitress"
  • "Great friendly staff."
  • "The staff were quick to apologise and replaced my meal with the one I ordered quite soon after the mistake was realised."
  • "The staff exelent very attentive."
  • "The staff couldn't do enough for you thanks again."
  • "Staff friendly and polite, gave us time and space to enjoy our long awaited catch up."

Cons:

  • "Never go here again. 20 minutes at bar to order drinks for the 4 of us it wasn't even busy."
  • "Staff useless don't even know the difference between red or white."
  • "Table service needs sorting, waiting 27 minutes for your drinks to arrive when sat in the heat outside is crazy."
  • "No senior management came to sort out the issue."
  • "Sat for ages at a table not knowing and not told that orders not taken at table."
  • "Waited for 15 minutes to be served at the bar, and still no one came."
  • "We were never offered menu's, I had to ask when there were 3 members of staff stood talking not far from our table."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere has always been great when we've been."
  • "The place has such a warm and positive vibe."
  • "Such a warm welcoming place ❤️ great selection of drinks, good offers on food."
  • "It's a good atmosphere."
  • "Was very busy, good atmosphere as there was a band playing for bank holiday."
  • "The atmosphere was great."
  • "The pub is tastefully decorated with a pleasant atmosphere."

Cons:

  • "They sat us at a table near a live band so having a conversation was impossible."
  • "It did make us feel uncomfortable."
  • "Not a very nice atmosphere. Shame really. It's a nice pub."
  • "Just awful, avoid 😖"
  • "No open mic at the Sitwell Arms Whiston any more.... Apparently it didn't make enough money..."
  • "What was a nice place to have a meal is now essentially a sports bar."
  • "We sat outside but the loud racket of 'music' was more akin to Blackpool North Pier than this otherwise pleasant pub."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.