Earl of Strafford Reviews Summary

Category: Pub Rotherham

Address: 11 Doncaster Rd, Hooton Roberts, Rotherham S65 4PF, United Kingdom

Phone: +441709913821

Rating: 4.0
based on 303 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Lovely meal at the earl of Strafford! Had really nice service in a relaxed atmosphere."
  • "We had the lamb shank for lunch and it was delicious."
  • "absolutely beautiful food in a lovely setting."
  • "The food was absolutely wonderful. I had the stroganoff which was rich and creamy with lovely tender beef."
  • "Great food and amazing staff."
  • "Food good, the 4 of us had 4 different meals and we all enjoyed them."
  • "The food was lovely."

Cons:

  • "The main course was either cold or shocking."
  • "Beef was like boot leather. Turkey and Pork equally as dry."
  • "Our meals were awful, I had pie but all the meat was in a big lump in the middle and the gravy was more like jelly."
  • "Unfortunately my classic burger was a let down."
  • "The beef had obviously been kept warm and was that awful grey colour."
  • "The food isn't awful, but it's very overpriced for the quality."
  • "The food was a big let down. I had pie and chips the pastry wasn't very good and the chips were soggy."

Service

Pros:

  • "Lovely attentive staff and gorgeous food."
  • "Service was great and I would definitely return."
  • "Service was attentive, but not smothering, perfect balance."
  • "Staff were very attentive & the manager made a real effort to make sure we had enjoyed ourselves."
  • "Paige went above and beyond with the service she gave us."
  • "Staff were friendly & apologetic."
  • "The waiting service is excellent and extremely attentive…"

Cons:

  • "Also the sarcasm from the management in relation to peoples review’s says a hell of a lot."
  • "Didnt get asked if all was ok? Didnt get asked anything really."
  • "They said the Manager was out and if we waited for an hour we could speak with them then, what a lame excuse."
  • "Reduced staffing meant it took 3 hours for 2 courses."
  • "After having to chase up our drinks order on multiple times and then the attitude of staff."
  • "Service was pretty bad. We ordered three rounds of drinks throughout the night and each took a long time to come, we had to ask for two rounds more than once."
  • "The service was absolutely appalling waiting 2 hours for the main course to come out and served by inexperienced staff who acted as though they wanted to be elsewhere."

Ambience & Decor

Pros:

  • "The refurb is lovely."
  • "The inn is so unique with its look and you can't help but be taken in by it."
  • "First timer, very impressive building with some original detail."
  • "Lovely place and definitely worth a visit."
  • "The event was well organised and had a beautiful welcome board."
  • "Fantastic decor, fantastic staff and exceptional food."
  • "Beautiful location. Lovely on the inside."

Cons:

  • "Unfortunately there were few other customers in and the decor is very dark so it wasn't a particularly good ambience."
  • "The only downside for me personally was that there was no cask ale on yet as it was still settling."
  • "The gravy was awful!! who puts strong herbs in gravy?"
  • "Such a beautiful building with so much potential yet serving microwaved food."
  • "The quality of the food was pretty poor, nothing like what it was pre-refurb."
  • "Atmosphere wise, it's apparently been refurbished recently. I disagree, there aren't two chairs the same and they're equally uncomfortable wooden ones."
  • "Place looks dull and lifeless and in need of a refurb."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.