Address: 29 Waterloo Pl, Edinburgh, EH1 3BQ, United Kingdom
Phone: +441315565766
Rating: 4.5
based on 470 reviews.
Food Quality
Pros:
"The best part of our meal was the haggis, which came as the main, tasty and not overwhelmingly flavoured."
"Each spoonful of this traditional Scottish soup felt like a journey through time, embracing the essence of local cuisine with its hearty flavours and comforting warmth."
"The meals were delicious and perfectly cooked."
"The food was simply amazing, bursting with flavor and prepared to perfection."
"The beef stew was especially good, the beef was tender and just melted in your mouth!"
"The most delicious haggis we ever had; as delicious was the traditional soup Cullen skink and a very special grilled lamb!"
"The food tasted amazing with such a beautiful interior to give extra warmth to customers."
Cons:
"The chicken was borderline too salty, it didn’t match with the sweet chutney and the flavour profile was unbalanced."
"Tried a few different wines but none particularly impressive."
"The vegetarian main was bland."
"Probably the worst ‘food’ I could have contemplated."
"Both the glasses of wine we had were really average, and I received a Merlot while I actually ordered a Malbec - hadn’t asked for a change as I didn’t want to waste it."
"Food is overpriced, the risotto had so much pepper it overpowered any other flavour."
"The main course I picked was fried salmon, but I found the flavor lacking; the salmon still had a fishy taste."
Service
Pros:
"Excellent service, ambiance, and food!"
"The staff were friendly and attentive."
"Service was excellent all through our meal."
"The staff were very professional, helpful & friendly."
"Service is superbly well organised despite being very busy."
"The wait staff were very knowledgeable, friendly and efficient."
"Staff were excellent - friendly, attentive, hard working."
Cons:
"Bar staff were also slow with our drinks, and one drink we ordered never arrived."
"Service was very slow servers keep dropping stuff round us as trying to carry too much at once."
"The staff's attitude was questionable."
"We were served by a moody waiter. He didn't give a shait until we finished the main course and then he suddenly became kind and pushy when he was asking if we want dessert and coffee, ofc only to get a good amount of tip."
"The young lady who served us has very bad attitude."
"However the service was a bit patchy. Ended up having 3 different servers."
"The waitress has such a horrible attitude towards my family."
Ambiance
Pros:
"It is a lovely place to eat with a great atmosphere."
"The ambiance was lovely, with a warm and inviting atmosphere."
"A beautiful meal with amazing atmosphere."
"The atmosphere feels both fun and smart."
"The restaurant is beautiful."
"I adored the beautiful, high-ceilinged space which felt bustling yet cozy at the same time."
"The atmosphere in the restaurant was lovely."
Cons:
"Biggest downside was the atmosphere which was somewhat lacking."
"Not to mention that the place was overpacked with tables close together which took away from the ambiance."
"Atmosphere was okay but the decor could use some updating."
"It is a large, relatively open plan, un-carpetted area and as such can be rather noisy."
"Very busy and, therefore, noisy, had to shout to be heard across the table."
"All the tables for regular guests is just in one room, so that is a drawback as it creates a lot of noise."
"The rude response and attitude really ruined our day, and no customer should face such a humiliation."
Value
Pros:
"Great food and reasonable prices."
"It is not the cheapest place but I believe it is worth it."
"The prices are really nice."
"It’s good value for money too."
"Enjoyed a great three course lunch with two cocktails for only £33."
"Great lunchtime 3 course deal meant that it was incredibly great value also."
"Excellent food for the price."
Cons:
"£28 for a fillet that I ordered medium rare but was medium and really chewy."
"We paid a lot only because of the restaurant's fancy look inside. But the food tasted ridiculously low quality for the price."
"Food is fresh and really well cooked."
"The portions are smaller and the price is higher than the city average, so overall it's bad value for money."
"Overpriced small portion of food with lower than expected quality and ridiculous service..."
"A bit expensive but delicious foods."
"The portions are not large—not like American standards—but the amounts were completely satisfactory."