Carlito Burrito Reviews Summary

Category: Mexican restaurant Brighton

Address: 12 York Pl, Brighton and Hove, Brighton BN1 4GU, United Kingdom

Phone: +441273671191

Rating: 4.4
based on 157 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The chicken quesadillas is my favourite thing on the menu. The pork burrito was also delicious and full of flavour."
  • "The food was incredible and we stuffed ourselves."
  • "The burrito was good. The chicken was tender and flavourful, teen rice was fresh together with the vegetables. Absolutely delicious."
  • "It was the best burrito and tacos that either of us have ever had."
  • "The tacos, burritos, nachos, all amazing easily my favourite in Brighton."
  • "Food cooked to perfection."
  • "Everything blew our minds with explosions of taste, especially the fish tacos, chicken burrito and chicken & chorizo tacos."

Cons:

  • "Last time I got the (amazing) fish tacos delivered they turned up in a box and had disintegrated."
  • "Quesadilla not folded so the filling spilled out. Undercooked rice in the burrito."
  • "The whole burrito is pretty much soaking wet."
  • "Slightly on the expensive side as I felt our vegetarian burrito was lacking in halloumi."
  • "ordered the chicken burrito..15 pound in total with guac and some salsa. one of the worst burritos I have ever had. Burrito 50% lettuce, it was not wrapped properly literally like a taco in foil lol and chicken was non-existent."
  • "The taco tortilla was quite soggy causing it to fall apart, the fish was just plain cod which is quite boring."
  • "The fish tacos had so much sauce you could only taste this."

Service

Pros:

  • "What a great vibe and service, one of the best Mexican places with cocktails and tequila to die for."
  • "Really impressed with the staff, there was one girl running the floor and even with six tables both outside and in, she was brilliant, no one was left waiting."
  • "Service was amazing too."
  • "The staff are amazing and the owner is often around working hard and encouraging a friendly atmosphere."
  • "Manager is so sweet and polite, she is a wonderful host."
  • "Great delivery experience."
  • "I’d like to especially give a shout out to Hettie and Paula for this, and for their amazing service."

Cons:

  • "Service was slow and we weren’t checked on at all during our visit."
  • "The staff are disorganised, forgetful and frankly come across as not really caring about the customers."
  • "Even water took ages to arrive and we only got it after the manageress told her waitress twice to bring the water over."
  • "Been trying to contact this establishment for months to enquire about catering a private event... but they don’t respond to emails, instagram messages or DMs."
  • "Service was pleasant enough but the young lady might have been new as not helpful."
  • "We stood by the door as requested for a while, people came and went!"
  • "Eventually a stressed out chap came over and barked 'yes' at me!"

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "Very vibrant and fun place!!"
  • "Carlito Burrito convinced me for the name and for the atmosphere outside and inside!"
  • "It is a very nice place. It has an amazing modern street Mexican style to it."
  • "The inside of the restaurant is rather intimate, so it can get a bit noisy at times (being seated so close to other tables) but has a lively, fun atmosphere."
  • "Inside is a level of cool my home decor can only aspire too!"
  • "The place is cool and edgy."
  • "Super Mexican food in a relaxed and very vibrant little restaurant."

Cons:

  • "The music was good but bit difficult to keep a conversation over as it was so loud so give 4 stars for the atmosphere."
  • "Just a note for those of us with sensory processing challenges. Early on this, place is great, but as with many places, the more people are, the more different noises to process."
  • "The atmosphere was flat, the restaurant smelled of cooking oil."
  • "Hygiene and cleanliness definitely suspect."
  • "Sadly, the quality of takeaway food has decreased greatly. Ordered some burritos yesterday which were 70% lettuce and near non-existent chorizo or halloumi."
  • "The restaurant itself is quite small and can get crowded very easily, but the ambiance is very colourful and warm."
  • "Really cool atmosphere."

Value

Pros:

  • "Check out their 2 margaritas for £10 offer on Sunday. It's a steal!"
  • "Food is very good. Lots of choice. Reasonable price."
  • "5 pound lunch burritos on weekdays are incredible value."
  • "In terms of pricing, Carlito's is very decent. You won't break the bank by coming here, and I feel the price is very worth it."
  • "For just over a tenner, you can have an incredible meal, which is excellent value."
  • "Drinks and food were top shelf, no complaints whatsoever. Prices aren't low, but are on track for Brighton."
  • "The tacos have a lot of substance (lots of steak, cilantro, avocado salsa), making it very worth the price as well."

Cons:

  • "Well we were both well off the mark as it came to £28!"
  • "Especially when you're paying £12 for two tacos."
  • "Slightly on the expensive side as I felt our vegetarian burrito was lacking in halloumi."
  • "For £11 per main we expected a bit more wow factor than what we received, which was a pretty standard take on Mexican street food."
  • "Especially painful when you pay more than 15 quid for one with added guacamole."
  • "We spent 40£ for a meal for two."
  • "But too small unfortunately, especially for its price."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.