Address: 12 York Pl, Brighton and Hove, Brighton BN1 4GU, United Kingdom
Phone: +441273671191
Rating: 4.4
based on 157 reviews.
Food Quality
Pros:
"The chicken quesadillas is my favourite thing on the menu. The pork burrito was also delicious and full of flavour."
"The food was incredible and we stuffed ourselves."
"The burrito was good. The chicken was tender and flavourful, teen rice was fresh together with the vegetables. Absolutely delicious."
"It was the best burrito and tacos that either of us have ever had."
"The tacos, burritos, nachos, all amazing easily my favourite in Brighton."
"Food cooked to perfection."
"Everything blew our minds with explosions of taste, especially the fish tacos, chicken burrito and chicken & chorizo tacos."
Cons:
"Last time I got the (amazing) fish tacos delivered they turned up in a box and had disintegrated."
"Quesadilla not folded so the filling spilled out. Undercooked rice in the burrito."
"The whole burrito is pretty much soaking wet."
"Slightly on the expensive side as I felt our vegetarian burrito was lacking in halloumi."
"ordered the chicken burrito..15 pound in total with guac and some salsa. one of the worst burritos I have ever had. Burrito 50% lettuce, it was not wrapped properly literally like a taco in foil lol and chicken was non-existent."
"The taco tortilla was quite soggy causing it to fall apart, the fish was just plain cod which is quite boring."
"The fish tacos had so much sauce you could only taste this."
Service
Pros:
"What a great vibe and service, one of the best Mexican places with cocktails and tequila to die for."
"Really impressed with the staff, there was one girl running the floor and even with six tables both outside and in, she was brilliant, no one was left waiting."
"Service was amazing too."
"The staff are amazing and the owner is often around working hard and encouraging a friendly atmosphere."
"Manager is so sweet and polite, she is a wonderful host."
"Great delivery experience."
"I’d like to especially give a shout out to Hettie and Paula for this, and for their amazing service."
Cons:
"Service was slow and we weren’t checked on at all during our visit."
"The staff are disorganised, forgetful and frankly come across as not really caring about the customers."
"Even water took ages to arrive and we only got it after the manageress told her waitress twice to bring the water over."
"Been trying to contact this establishment for months to enquire about catering a private event... but they don’t respond to emails, instagram messages or DMs."
"Service was pleasant enough but the young lady might have been new as not helpful."
"We stood by the door as requested for a while, people came and went!"
"Eventually a stressed out chap came over and barked 'yes' at me!"
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Very vibrant and fun place!!"
"Carlito Burrito convinced me for the name and for the atmosphere outside and inside!"
"It is a very nice place. It has an amazing modern street Mexican style to it."
"The inside of the restaurant is rather intimate, so it can get a bit noisy at times (being seated so close to other tables) but has a lively, fun atmosphere."
"Inside is a level of cool my home decor can only aspire too!"
"The place is cool and edgy."
"Super Mexican food in a relaxed and very vibrant little restaurant."
Cons:
"The music was good but bit difficult to keep a conversation over as it was so loud so give 4 stars for the atmosphere."
"Just a note for those of us with sensory processing challenges. Early on this, place is great, but as with many places, the more people are, the more different noises to process."
"The atmosphere was flat, the restaurant smelled of cooking oil."
"Hygiene and cleanliness definitely suspect."
"Sadly, the quality of takeaway food has decreased greatly. Ordered some burritos yesterday which were 70% lettuce and near non-existent chorizo or halloumi."
"The restaurant itself is quite small and can get crowded very easily, but the ambiance is very colourful and warm."
"Really cool atmosphere."
Value
Pros:
"Check out their 2 margaritas for £10 offer on Sunday. It's a steal!"
"Food is very good. Lots of choice. Reasonable price."
"5 pound lunch burritos on weekdays are incredible value."
"In terms of pricing, Carlito's is very decent. You won't break the bank by coming here, and I feel the price is very worth it."
"For just over a tenner, you can have an incredible meal, which is excellent value."
"Drinks and food were top shelf, no complaints whatsoever. Prices aren't low, but are on track for Brighton."
"The tacos have a lot of substance (lots of steak, cilantro, avocado salsa), making it very worth the price as well."
Cons:
"Well we were both well off the mark as it came to £28!"
"Especially when you're paying £12 for two tacos."
"Slightly on the expensive side as I felt our vegetarian burrito was lacking in halloumi."
"For £11 per main we expected a bit more wow factor than what we received, which was a pretty standard take on Mexican street food."
"Especially painful when you pay more than 15 quid for one with added guacamole."
"We spent 40£ for a meal for two."
"But too small unfortunately, especially for its price."