Pizza Pilgrims Shoreditch Reviews Summary

Service

Pros:

• "The service was friendly and they managed to sit a party of 6 despite a busy service."
• "My recent visit to Pizza Pilgrims in Shoreditch was exceptional, thanks to Simone's fantastic menu recommendations and prompt service."
• "Staff is super friendly, the ambiance is great and the food is superb!!"
• "Such a wonderful experience! The staff were all brilliant - it really felt like they loved their work."

Cons:

• "Service was slow. I think they forgot about us at some point."
• "Staff are not attentive at all, they are very slow and the vibe is off."
• "Service was bad. Beer was served with a hair floating in the head."
• "It took 20 mins for someone to get our order, even after asking multiple times & 45+ minutes to get the food."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The pizza was lovely. There is halal option available and you can add extra on your pizza."
• "This is definitely the BEST pizza place in London, proper Italian I loved it."
• "One of the best pizzas I've ever eaten. Classic Italian pizza. Thin crust plus excellent toppings."
• "The pizza itself was good, but I had better. It had a chewy dough which I liked."

Cons:

• "The only down point was the speed of pizza preparation which was quite slow."
• "The pizza was devine and the dips were yummy. I just had the margarita and had to finish it all."
• "Found the pizza here a bit wet and sloppy. It more or less falls apart when you pick it up."
• "Ordered a pizza fiorentina, after ages it arrived and it look nothing like the real thing."

Ambiance and Location

Pros:

• "Visited unbooked last Saturday evening. We were warned on entry that we could sit but food service would be slow."
• "Nice staff, clean toilet. Little poky upstairs with lots of tables but cute vibe."
• "Super cute corner shop, amazing pizza and nice cold beers with plenty of other options on the menu."
• "Cute, busy little pizza place. Many have told me that they think it's the best pizza...I agree!"

Cons:

• "Space is a bit cramped and hot. Price was fine. There’s definitely nicer pizzas to be had in London."
• "Smelled heavily of toilet cleaner, which was quite overpowering to the point we nearly decided to leave."
• "Front of house are completely useless. Been here twice and told there are no tables when the restaurant is empty."
• "Very busy and we were waiting a lot to be served. However the staff were very kind and responsive."