Tony Macaroni Reviews Summary

Service

Pros:

• "The service the staff provided us with was great and made our day out even better!"
• "Service was impeccable, food was delicious and served quickly, beer was ice cold, atmosphere was nice."
• "Had a lovely dinner (3 course meal) food was lovely and brought out quick our waitress roberta was absolutely lovely and sweet will defo be back there again thank you for a lovely meal on our anniversary xoxo"
• "She was very friendly and super funny! Very good service, great food, excellent mocktails."
• "The only shining light was a young employee called Rebecca. She was very helpful."
• "The waiter was friendly and attentive."
• "The staff were very polite and service was efficient....one waiter entered into regular banter with my daughter which she enjoyed greatly."

Cons:

• "We were not the only table having issues."
• "The waiter became rather rude."
• "Between staff actually running in restaurant & rushing u to finish ur food!!"
• "Waiters were not particularly that friendly either."
• "Service was slow 3 starters served 1 had a wait."
• "Shocking disgusting behaviour. Daughter still eating her desert and waiter came up asked why we were still sitting."
• "Service was extremely slow, was sat there for 45 or so minutes just waiting for the staff to come over to let us order our food."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "Service was impeccable, food was delicious and served quickly, beer was ice cold, atmosphere was nice."
• "Had a lovely dinner (3 course meal) food was lovely and brought out quick our waitress roberta was absolutely lovely and sweet will defo be back there again thank you for a lovely meal on our anniversary xoxo"
• "Also, the best garlic bread I've ever had, like it was fried in butter or something."
• "Had a craving for Italian and Tony delivered! One of the best pizzas I have ever eaten."
• "Highly recommend Mr. Macaroni's pizza!"
• "The pasta dishes that came to the table were very tasty."
• "Food was delicious, never had a bad meal in this place!"

Cons:

• "First visit to this particular Tony Macaroni Had the seafood linguine 5 of the 7 clams weren't open only 3 prawns and 2 small squid rings it was drowned in olive oil not impressed at all."
• "The salad with the sides (squid, calamary and prawns) was rotten."
• "My pasta dish was soggy, it tasted like it had been lying about for a day or two."
• "Of the meals ordered we found the pizza was rather salty, the lasagna was too cheesy and the risotto was okay."
• "Mozzarella was in a ball, not sliced, Macaroni cheese was rotten & chicken burger was cold."
• "My arincini were still half frozen in the middle."
• "Food was bland and tasteless, my partner who never puts salt on his food added salt to his pasta."

Value for Money

Pros:

• "7/10 for prices."
• "Prices are reasonable especially for Edinburgh."
• "We went for the lunchtime specials- food was quick, tasty and hot, not to mention a lot more that we expected for under £7!"
• "The lunchtime menu (weekdays) is such a bargain and has plenty to offer."
• "The menu is very varied and the value for money is pretty good."

Cons:

• "Lunchtime deal menu is very deceiving in its pricing."
• "The final bill was more than £20 for 2."
• "Then the bill came and WATCH OUT!! They add a 10% tip on automatically no matter what, if you ask or don’t."
• "Also the optional service charge and I will repeat optional was already added onto my bill."
• "Drinks expensive £4:95 for a beer!!"
• "Even on the bill we have been cheated on with an 5% service charge already added on us."
• "It certainly was not worth the £50 we paid overall."