Proove Pizza Reviews Summary

Category: Pizza restaurant Sheffield

Address: 261 Fulwood Rd, Broomhill, Sheffield, S10 3BD, United Kingdom

Phone: +441142945185

Rating: 4.5
based on 161 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Probably the best calzone I’ve had."
  • "Amazing pizza even for the Italian standards, the pizza bread is so soft, and the edges are never burnt."
  • "Delicious dough balls and diavola pizza with a great wine selection to go with things."
  • "The Pizza had a very subtle woody taste which complimented the tomato sauce."
  • "These were by far the best pizzas we have ever eaten."
  • "The best gluten free pizza I've ever tasted."
  • "Absolutely amazing, authentic, delicious pizza - as it's supposed to be!"

Cons:

  • "Very disappointing pizza. Marguerita pizza had a tablespoon of tomato base and a minute amount of mozzarella cheese with a dried up basil leaf in the middle."
  • "The Americana pizza was very chewy and the peppers in there were soggy rather than ‘roasted’."
  • "The Carni Calzone was so salty that we struggled to eat it."
  • "The restaurant and seating is nice, with a large room downstairs. The staff were welcoming and friendly. The pizzas were not amazing - burnt in places on the large crust from the oven, but soggy and doughy in the middle."
  • "Worst pizza I've ever eaten...can't fault the staff though they were great."
  • "The pizza crust was really raw and soggy."
  • "Pizza dough was burnt on the outside, raw on the inside."

Service

Pros:

  • "Service Was friendly and very polite."
  • "The service was great. Our waitress was friendly and always had a smile."
  • "One of the nicest pizzas I've ever had, extremely friendly service, could not believe the speed the food came out."
  • "The staff were excellent. Service was with a broad smile, efficient and accurate."
  • "All the staff were polite and cheerful and quick to recommend different dishes."
  • "Lovely pizzas and friendly staff."
  • "The staff couldn't have been better they were so great with the kids, the chef in particular was brilliant and very patient helping them make pizza."

Cons:

  • "Service was a little slow the most recent time we visited."
  • "Deliveroo orders seem to take precedence and we waited 90 minutes for 2 pizzas."
  • "Service fine but a little perfunctory and it was very hot."
  • "Really badly run and I ended up waiting nearly 3 hours for a pizza to arrive."
  • "20 mins to be asked what drinks we wanted and then sat 30 mins waiting for dessert to arrive so just got up and left."
  • "Proove has seriously gone downhill. 45 minute wait just for our drinks."
  • "Service was poor, order was wrong."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "They have a good selection of drinks the wine was excellent."
  • "Friendly staff and good selection of drinks to wash it all down with."
  • "The place is quite small and cosy they have a traditional wood fired oven which makes the base taste excellent."
  • "Very relaxed, chilled atmosphere."
  • "Really nice atmosphere here too and great service."
  • "Nice atmosphere and friendly service."
  • "The restaurant itself was warm and cozy. Lovely decor and relaxing atmosphere."

Cons:

  • "The only negative thing was that our table was downstairs and it felt a bit cold."
  • "Pizza ok, little atmosphere."
  • "Lastly the bathroom was absolutely disgusting. Looked like it hadn't been cleaned for days."
  • "The blonde waiter could of been more genuinely friendly."
  • "A bit disappointed as the pizza edge is very thick and blank."
  • "Overall expensive and very disappointing."
  • "Pizza bottom burnt. Was like eating charcoal."

Value

Pros:

  • "The prices were reasonable."
  • "Ordered for collection and it was ready within 5 mins."
  • "Excellent value lunch menu with good range of 10” pizza options, lovely side order of caprese salad and drink, all for £10.90."
  • "And the price was affordable for everyone."
  • "Price was good. They also have offers during the week."
  • "Prices are amazing."
  • "Ordered off a lunchtime deal menu where you can get a pizza (8in i think), a side and a drink all for under £10!"

Cons:

  • "50p for a small pot of chilli oil was a bit much though, especially as we weren't told it would cost anything."
  • "Nice pizza but a bit pricey."
  • "Slightly pricey but understandable given the quality of the ingredients."
  • "I ordered the diavola pizza which was £11.70, probably a bit on the pricey side?"
  • "More expensive than some similar establishments, I ended up feeling underwhelmed by this one."
  • "Very disappointing. Definitely not worth £8.50!!!"
  • "I've been waiting 2.5 hours for a small pizza that I paid 14.86 on Deliveroo."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.