The Blacksmiths Reviews Summary

Category: Pub Newport

Address: Calbourne Rd, Newport, PO30 5SS, United Kingdom

Phone: +441983529263

Rating: 4.7
based on 252 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Best food on the Isle Of Wight without a doubt! Every time I have been, the food has been well presented, fresh ingredients and delicious!!"
  • "The food was just perfect! Highly recommend the fish platter, special (if still available) and their pie!"
  • "Food, service and atmosphere all first class."
  • "The food was amazing, good portions and choices."
  • "Food was simply amazing 🤩 presentation and taste first class."
  • "The food was excellent with great portions and clearly cooked fresh and served nice and hot."
  • "The food is delicious, beautiful views and all the staff were great."

Cons:

  • "The signature pie was poor: good pastry and delicious lamb ruined by unpleasant sauce/gravy and tough vegetables."
  • "The burger worst meat I have ever seen, the scampi was rough."
  • "Very disappointed with the food."
  • "Had not visited in a while, ordered the beef burgers which sadly ended up being frozen burgers :( this was very disappointing!"
  • "The only comment on the food, apart from we all enjoyed it, was that the mayonnaise ordered for chips came out in a skimpy ramekin and tasted like a budget brand, too much vinegar."
  • "I had chicken Caesar salad,the chicken was pr-cooked and hard,the chicken is supposed to be tender succulent strips, not chicken portions"
  • "T bone steak, too much seasoning for my liking and the cut was very boney with a lot of fat."

Service

Pros:

  • "The staff are really friendly too!"
  • "The staff are friendly and helpful and the service quick."
  • "Staff where very friendly and the drinks good too."
  • "Highly recommended, friendly staff and great service."
  • "The service was quick, friendly and helpful."
  • "The staff attentive and efficient."
  • "Staff were attentive without being overbearing knowledgeable and welcoming."

Cons:

  • "Staff were very absent, would have been nice for them to come round to check everything was ok during the meal."
  • "An extremely unfriendly waitress who seemed incapable of interacting or smiling."
  • "The staff seemed uncoordinated and few team members meant delays on drinks orders arriving promptly."
  • "Service was terrible waited at the bar for ages to be seated."
  • "Then when seated no one came to take our drinks order till we asked 15 minutes later."
  • "The service was rude, challenging and unhelpful."
  • "The service was awful,the waitress did not smile greet or introduce herself."

Ambience & Location

Pros:

  • "Stunning views from the conservatory windows being able to see for miles."
  • "Wonderful views over the Island."
  • "We sat outside and the views were gorgeous as well."
  • "The dining area had the most amazing panoramic views and so picturesque."
  • "The atmosphere is also nice, with the place being surrounded by beautiful views."
  • "Lovely pub in the countryside with fantastic views over farm fields."
  • "Lovely pub with large garden and lots of seating, children's play frame, great location, 180° views towards mainland."

Cons:

  • "When we arrived on the day we have been directed to the dark part of the pub."
  • "Sat us by ourselves in the dark front room away from amazing views on one of the few sunny days!"
  • "Unpleasant experience. We might visit again, I don’t know...probably not very soon."
  • "Really lovely food! Shame about the abundance of dogs.....fine outside in the summer, but not indoors!"
  • "A terrible experience."
  • "Felt like I had been sent to sit on the ‘naughty step’."
  • "It used to be a lovely friendly place, but the service we received in the garden made us feel like lepers."

Accessibility & Facilities

Pros:

  • "There is a playground for young children and smoking and non smoking seating outside."
  • "Decent play area for the kids too."
  • "With a nice outside kids play area and plenty of outside seating."
  • "Also the play area and the view are another bonus when the kids can have a run around too!"
  • "A large kids play area outside provides a diversion for fidgets."
  • "Small kids play area which is ideal and two large car parks for plenty of parking."
  • "Beautiful lunch served incredibly quick and fresh, lovely setting with the sun shining and views out over the countryside and out to the Solent."

Cons:

  • "No wheelchair access so if one of your party is disabled you will struggle."
  • "Limited space for people who cannot do steps or multiple changes in floor levels ...parking can be difficult in busy times."
  • "The only tiny downside is it is difficult to get a table without reservation, and the car park is a little treacherous to navigate, but I'm looking for flaws."
  • "The only downside is the parking, which can be awkward at times. The car park isn’t fantastic and, obviously, because it is popular it can be difficult to get parked."
  • "We also ended up paying twice because a payment was initially pending as the app caused problems."
  • "Only downside is ordering via an app which didn't work too well."
  • "But their app to order hung up and delayed our order."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.