Pizza Pilgrims Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "This was undoubtedly some of the best pizza I have had in my entire life."
• "Creamy, melted mozzarella cheese, fresh tomatoes, delicious baked ham, mushrooms and condiments."
• "Proper authentic pizza."
• "Beautiful authentic neopolitan pizza and the mozzarella bites are to die for."
• "Really delicious pizza, some of the best I've had outside of Italy, no doubt."
• "The margherita was very nice indeed, on par with the best neapolitan pizzerias in london."
• "One of the best pizzas I've ever eaten in my life. Incredible flavours, tasty and fluffy crust."

Cons:

• "Nasty pizza which was far from good, the margarita was swimming in sauce and hardly had any cheese."
• "Both were bad, with dry texture, mushy thick dough and very little flavour."
• "The pizza was so watery."
• "The pizza itself also wasn’t great. It had flavor but the dough was super soggy on the bottom and too doughy on the outside."
• "Piza burnt-out, the one w aubergine, i guess, bread crumbs, who would need extra bread on pizza?"
• "Pizza was fine, could have done with a little more tomato sauce, 30 seconds less in the oven, and maybe a slightly less generous helping of burrata."
• "I ordered a margherita and I received one of the worst piazz's I have even eaten."

Service

Pros:

• "Service was good overall, staff kind and polite enough."
• "The service provided by FABIANA (super friendly and professional) was amazing as she took care of us throughout the dinner."
• "Staff was helpful, prompt and cheerful."
• "The staff were amazing! They even helped me the boys get to the best train station to get home on."
• "We were kindly served by Amy (grazie mille, bello) and it’s our favorite place for aperitivo around already."
• "The service was impeccable and she was so kind and was able to explain everything on the menu to us, obviously very well trained."
• "I stumbled upon to this old lovely Italian restaurant a few days ago by chance, and I had the pleasure of experiencing exceptional service from a waiter named Jenay."

Cons:

• "The server was completely idiotic."
• "The service wasn’t great, they seemed annoyed we were there, didn’t check on us, etc."
• "Upon asking for the bill the waitress just walked off to change the Spotify playlist rather than to the till and then walked off."
• "The staff didn't seem to care about service."
• "The service is good and quick and the pizzas were excellent."
• "The service was very disappointing... the waitress got the order wrong."
• "The service let it down."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "You can either perch outside or you can sit downstairs in their cosy dining area."
• "Really nice rough and ready yet kind of chic decor and ambiance."
• "Great atmosphere."
• "A spacious and cozy pizzeria with a young adult attitude."
• "Open kitchen so you can see everything being made (fun 😃)."
• "Everything around is playful, cheerful and sleek with an American college atmosphere."
• "Lovely decorated restaurant, which has a very pleasant atmosphere."

Cons:

• "There were flies and nothing felt too clean."
• "The energy was so flat and unwelcoming."
• "The atmosphere was relaxed and chilled."
• "The atmosphere was fine, appreciate it was an afternoon but had someone on a teams call without headphones a few metres away that ruined the vibe."
• "The underground bomb shelter bit is way too noisy - made it really hard to hear each other."
• "Place was way too noisy."
• "It was slightly cold inside hence the 4 stars for atmosphere."

Value

Pros:

• "Also not that expensive price with good quality."
• "£7.50 for a tasty classic."
• "The quality of the food is outstanding and it’s a good value for money!!"
• "The food was very reasonably priced and tasted amazing. It was out cheapest dinner in London and probably our favourite."
• "Everything is very reasonably priced!"
• "It is also very good value for money with my friends pizza being £8.95 and mine £10.95."
• "Excellent value and extremely tasty authentic pizzas."

Cons:

• "The small aperol spritz was so tiny in comparison to the large but the price is almost the same, what a rip off."
• "My biggest annoyance is that they add a 12.5% service charge onto your bill (without telling you beforehand)."
• "And then they ask for a tip on top of that when they give you the card machine to pay, with a range starting at 15%."
• "Does take service charge so beware."
• "However it is significantly smaller than the standard neapolitan pizza at the regular price so only 4*."
• "Had a buffalo margarita- Pizza not as tasty as it used to be and had no seasoning."
• "Overall, the place is overrated and overpriced just for a basic pizza!!!"