Tony Macaroni Reviews Summary

Category: Italian restaurant Edinburgh

Address: Fort Kinnaird, Newcraighall Rd, Edinburgh, EH15 3RD, United Kingdom

Phone: +441313221143

Rating: 4.0
based on 132 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food looked nice and tasted nice, all food was eaten and enjoyed."
  • "Wonderful family experience. The food was great all round. Really nice pizza πŸ•"
  • "Great food for the price!"
  • "Food was excellent but it was so cold inside the restaurant we couldn't enjoy ourselves."
  • "First time here and the food was excellent. We had spaghetti carbonara and spaghetti bolognese so nothing adventurous but both dishes were lovely."
  • "Food is good quality. Really nice but the menu is huge and it took us that long to decide what we wanted we almost left."
  • "Really good place to eat, good portions and nice staff, a wee bit pricey at peak times but still worth a visit as they also have good meal deals (check website) good PPE and social distancing."
  • "Had a good lunch of pepper and tomato soup, sweet potato fries and a side salad. The rose wine was good and the tiramisu delicious!"

Cons:

  • "The food is terrible, I wonder if the chefs taste what they’re serving."
  • "Most watery pasta on the planet."
  • "Lasagne was bland and sat in a bowl of thin tomato sauce."
  • "The puddings ordered made up somewhat but overall not the authentic Italian dining experience advertised."
  • "It was honestly the worst macaroni cheese I've had."
  • "Very quiet with little atmosphere. Service mediocre, had to go over to bar to order another drink as staff were not attentive."
  • "The food was quite bland in taste. Lasagne was watery almost."
  • "Poor service!! poor customer service!! Rude workers!!"

Service and Staff

Pros:

  • "Staff very friendly, no issues at all."
  • "Nice restaurant, friendly attentive and hard working staff, excellent service."
  • "We were a larger group on Sunday, the waitresses were very nice and helpful."
  • "Wonderful family experience. Really nice pizza. Didn’t wait long on the orders, so it was a nice service and friendly staff."
  • "Excellent choice of food, fast, tasty, great service."
  • "We had excellent, prompt and efficient service on our visit. The waiter was very helpful and chatty but also good with our son."
  • "We all love Tony Macaroni!!! The food is always amazing and so are the staff."
  • "The staff here are fantastic. We attend regularly due to a family member living close by who isn't well at times. The staff understand this and are very accommodating."

Cons:

  • "Overall service was below average."
  • "Waited a while even though it was empty but the starters were good."
  • "The first Euro Italian restaurant I visited and it was 'meh'."
  • "The room was quite cold. The service was too slow for at the time a quiet restaurant."
  • "Poor service!! poor customer service!! Rude workers!!"
  • "Waited a long time for starters and a long wait between meals."
  • "The staff had had a Barney with each other leaving the manager being beyond rude to us."
  • "Not impressed. The waitress dropped chips off the plate when trying to put it on the table."

Atmosphere and Cleanliness

Pros:

  • "Atmosphere? Unfair because it was a rainy Wednesday lunch time."
  • "The decor is tired, veneer on the table was lifting and small bits missing."
  • "Staff are lovely and the decor and atmosphere is exactly like you'd expect."
  • "Really enjoyed our visit. Great friendly servers and a good atmosphere."
  • "Family meal was fantastic. Seating area was very nice. Staff very pleasant and accommodating."
  • "Very nice and attentive staff. Food is good. Busy on a Sunday afternoon, but we were seated quickly and served promptly."
  • "Came here for a family meal, the staff was very friendly, the place was clean, the food was delicious."
  • "First time here and definitely be back. Good food and service. The children's menu was lovely and good value, not your usual garbage that is trundled out for children."

Cons:

  • "Freezing cold the staff wore body warmers and and place had an oil filled heater by the till putting out very little heat."
  • "Unisex toilets were not clean, embarrassing dirty!"
  • "The room was quite cold. The service was too slow for at the time a quiet restaurant."
  • "Unfortunately the pasta sauce was quite bland/watery."
  • "The food was rubbish, spaghetti bolognaise was horrible tasted like tomato purΓ©e."
  • "Waited over 15 minutes for someone to take our order!"
  • "Freezing cold inside, staff arguing with each other, customers sat with coats and hats on."
  • "What a disappointment! Toilets were filthy - not just a missed clean but long-standing grime."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.